The Big Bike Travel Bag Shootout

Welcome to Tour de France Tips - the website for planning a cycling trip to France for Le Tour, L'Etape or just leisure. The website is full of useful information, facts and ideas to help you plan a great trip to France. For an all-in-one guide, check out the extensive Guide to Cycling Through France ebook.

You can also keep up to date by subscribing to our new products/downloads mailing list (I give free stuff away often!) or the RSS feed for all new posts. Thanks for visiting!

In this post I video-compare the EVOC, Scicon Aero Comfort Plus, Polaris (and OEM) Bike Pods and Airline Bike Box.

In this post I compared the latter 4 and now need to add the EVOC.

You can get the EVOC using the below links. Disclosure: these are affiliate links.

• Wiggle + Road bike adaptor kit (if those links don’t work, try this link for the bag and this link for the adaptor)
• Chain Reaction Cycles + road bike adaptor kit (RBAK) – (if those links don’t work, try this link for the bag and this link for the RBAK).
• ProBikeKit + Road bike adaptor kit,(if those links don’t work, try this link for the bag and this link for the adaptor)

You can watch the video, then read the summary. I’ve assigned a score to each bag based on a number of metrics, which I’ve also weighted according to what I look for in a bike bag.

My overall scores are based on the following metrics. Your weightings may of course change according to what you think is important. To this end, I’ve made my score sheet available for download as an Excel spreadsheet, so you can change your weightings, apply my scores, and see how the scores change.

Keep in mind my raw scores are subjective as well. If I scored a bag poorly in terms of construction/design, this might be according to how it performed in my experience; you might score it entirely differently. As an example, one of my friends would score the Scicon a lot higher in terms of how it protects the bike. However, because I believe the Scicon needs a lot of extra padding inserted in order to protect the bike, I scored it fairly low.

The Scores
Keep in mind the pros and cons of the last 4 bags listed are discussed in this post.

To summarise the EVOC:
Pros:

• Very affordable (for what you get)
• Excellent construction both in terms of quality and how it has been thought out
• Extremely agile
• Lots of padding
• Durable

Cons:

• Weight, though at 9kg, it’s not terrible. I mainly put this in the cons for balance as it doesn’t have any real disadvantages! This is a cracker bag!

So, to the winner! Clearly I rate the EVOC the highest. It’s overall utility is very high. It has loads of storage for the bike and cycling/casual clothing (enough for a few days away) and is very adjustable.

It’s been well thought out (fibreglass stringers) and protects the bike.

It is designed to survive the knocks of international travel (bash material) and be baggage handler and user-friendly (handles, wheels).

You can get the EVOC using the below links. Disclosure: these are affiliate links.

• Wiggle + Road bike adaptor kit (if those links don’t work, try this link for the bag and this link for the adaptor)
• Chain Reaction Cycles + road bike adaptor kit (RBAK) – (if those links don’t work, try this link for the bag and this link for the RBAK).
• ProBikeKit + Road bike adaptor kit,(if those links don’t work, try this link for the bag and this link for the adaptor)

Mailing List

If you haven't, please sign up to the VeloNomad mailing list for all the great tips and tricks delivered straight to your inbox (once a week usually).

Did I Answer Your Question? Got a topic suggestion?

Tell me what information you need in the Comments below!